Scenes when you really do or don't love D and M

[snappysara]

BE SPONTANEOUS.... NO THINKING TOO LONG and you can have another go at any time...

Ok here goes for starters:

I really don't love David when he throws up in Maddies car in 'The Son also rises'
I really do love him when he tells Maddie he believes in her in 'Read the mind, see the movie'

I really don't love Maddie when she tells David that SHE is exactly who he wants to be with in 'To Heiress Human'

I really do love Maddie when she grabs David's hand and tells him to 'keep grasping' in the Pilot.

[sandra]

Oh, nice idea, Snap! Okay, spontaneously - as there are countless scenes where I love them!!

I don't like Maddie in TTTM in the car conversation, when she says "you know what ambivalent means?"

I love her in Atlas Belched when she offers her help: "Hire me!"

I don't like David when he acts like a (desperate) idiot in the dinner-crashing scene in Sam & Dave.

I love him in the final scene of LITIM: "You're forgiven, partner."

[goldilocks]

What a great idea, Snap!!!! Here we go:

I really DO love:

Maddie when she says: "I am glad you are my partner, PARTNER." and gives him a kiss. ("The Lady in the Iron Mask")

David when he calls her Madolyn

I really DO NOT love:

Maddie when she says: "We are pals" to David. ("The Color of Maddie (?))

David when he says: "Nothing about the garage" ("Witness for the Execution")

[snappysara]

HAHAHAHA great answers Sandra and Goldie

Here are a couple more from SnappitySnap

I Really don't love David when he lies on the plane about going to his brother in laws funeral in Mulberry
but... i absolutely REALLY REALLY love him when he says 'she didn't even ask me to go with her' in Money Talks Maddie Walks.

I really don't love Maddie when she dances with Richie instead of David in the bar in Brother can you spare a blonde but..
I Really love her when she tells McGillacuddy that she hopes he'll stay in It's a wonderful job.

[finefinegoodgood]

Ok here we go....

I LOVE when David says I love you...lets keep trying.

I dont LOVE David when he sleeps with Annie!!!

I LOVE Maddie when she comes home from Chicago and the first look she gives to David

I dont LOVE Maddie when she tells David shes married!

[iluvdavid]

Love:
Maddie when she says she missed David in "The Son Also Rises" and when she looks at David lovingly
David when he brings Maddie the rose in "Symphony in Knocked Flat' and all the times he tries to woo her.
Hate:
Maddie in the laundromat scene in "A Trip to the Moon"
David in the scene outside of Maddie's house when he is begging to take her out. (it is painful).

[snappysara]

Kim- 'lets keep trying' is a fab choice and iluvdavid - 'missed you' is also great. xxxxx Keep em coming folks....

[1987]

I really DON'T love David when he tells Maddie to "get out of his bed." in When Girls Collide.... all the way through their last encounter in Maddie's office in Lunar Eclipse.

I really DON'T love Maddie when she says "let's gamble" in Tracks of My Tears.

I really love David at the end of both Christmas episodes. Swoon.

I really love Maddie when she appears in a dark hotel room offering support (and consumed with curiosity) in Big Man on Mulberry St.

[mackidockie]

Sept 5, 2011 16:33:58 GMT -5 finefinegoodgood said:

Ok here we go....

I LOVE when David says I love you...lets keep trying.

I dont LOVE David when he sleeps with Annie!!!

I LOVE Maddie when she comes home from Chicago and the first look she gives to David

I dont LOVE Maddie when she tells David shes married!

Can't believe we have the same 'I LOVE' and 'I don't LOVE'!

And I really hate David when he sleeps with Annie, and I really hate Maddie when she comes back married.

[witness]

I absolutely love Maddie when on the stairs in "Atlas Belched" asks David with genuine concern, "I thought you had a big appt with an important client. Didn't everything go well?" She wants him to start off on a good foot with his own agency.

I don't love Maddie when she says matter-of-factly in "Tracks of My Tears," "It's not yours."

I love David when he stands behind Maddie in her office in "Portrait of Maddie" and talks her through the upsetting news she's just received. Of course, 3-4 sentences in he cracks a joke, but that's quintessential David.

That's why I can't at this point come up with a "I don't love David when" because everything seems to be just who he is. I could steal 1987's "Get out of my bed" from WGC, because that's not who he is and why it makes the line so ugly. I'll try to come up with one on my own.

[treasmus]

I really like the scene in "Portrait of Maddie" where Maddie blows David a kiss in the car.

I really like the scene in "Money Talks, Maddie Walks" where David kisses Maddie's hand.

I really like the part of the elevator scene in "Between a Yuk and a Hard Place" where Maddie breaks down and David holds her and then they hold eachother and comfort eachother.

I really dislike the scene in "Money Talks, Maddie Walks" where David says to Maddie (who is about to talk to the guy who's about to jump off a building) "Whatever you do, don't take your shirt off."

I really dislike the scene before the food fight in "The Murder's in the Mail" where Maddie is dressed in a maid's outfit and David suggestively looks down her shirt.

Sept 5, 2011 16:21:31 GMT -5 sandra said:

I don't like Maddie in TTTM in the car conversation, when she says "you know what ambivalent means?

This has to be one of the only times when I don't like something Maddie says or does.

[sandra]

Sept 6, 2011 2:08:52 GMT -5 witness said:

That's why I can't at this point come up with a "I don't love David when" because everything seems to be just who he is.

That sums pretty much up my problem with this part...

[finefinegoodgood]

I love David when he and Maddie are standing in the doorway of the office and David tells Maddie the truth about her father...and it truly hurts him to do so....

I love when Maddie says to David "missed you" as David is walking out the door.

I dont love David when he dont go to Chicago to get Maddie!

I dont love Maddie when she makes pacts.

[beesnbears]

I wanna play, I wanna play!

I LOVE David when Maddie returns from Chicago and he's standing by his office door, just looking at her, hands in his pockets, head slightly tilted, a twinkle in his eyes.

I LOVE Maddie when, while she is in Chicago, she receives the package of books from David and then goes and packs her things to go home. That whole exchange between her parents gets me everytime.


I don't like....just don't like....never hate these two...when they avoid each other in "Between a Yuk..." after Maddie loses the baby.

I get really mad at David...still don't hate... when he sleeps with Annie.

I get really mad at Maddie when she marries Walter.

...makes me want to shake'em, grab'em by their ears and put'em in a corner nose to nose!!

[bluemoonshampoo]

Let's give it a go:

I LOVE Maddie when she lies to the police for David in Witness

I LOVE David when he writes to Maddie in Chicago and tells her 'this is a bunch of crap, I'm lonely and I want you to come home'

I Hate Maddie when she leaves David with false hope in the laundromat

I Hate David when he doesn't jump straight on a plane to Chicago when he finds out Maddie is pregnant...

Ooh I enjoyed that- I'll do some more later :-) x