We know she slept with him the night that David got drunk but I am not sure about the following night. I would like to think no..lol but probably. When she does come home and he mentions what he wants to do or wants her to do and Maddie thinks he is referring to sex she acts annoyed.
Post by istanforthee on Oct 22, 2012 20:28:25 GMT -5
Okay, so if Maddie really thought it was Sam's baby, why didn't we get to hear anything about Sam? When David asks her about Sam, she always says it's none of his business. Why didn't she tell him? If she truly believed it was Sam's baby, she would've/should've told him. It's the father's right to know and it's Maddies character to do what's right. I don't get this.
Maybe deep down she thinks it's David's. The "sonogram and calendars" say otherwise but I don't think she was convinced. Also, in the episode To Heiress Human, when they were in the car at the end, we get an inkling that Maddie might get pregnant by David. He asked her in the car if she's taking birth control because he didn't use protection. She said yes, and they have relations for a month. I don't know why the writers would push this idea that it's not David's baby. This whole thing confuses me. Ugh!
Post by maddieaddisonjr on Apr 3, 2016 22:05:52 GMT -5
I think continuity was thrown out the window for the sake of whatever kind of episode they wanted to write. It's not even up for debate, folks. Maddie had been in Chicago for 4 and a half months. When she got back she told the Wobblies she was less than 5 months pregnant. According to David they had been sleeping together consistently for 1 month. This means that Sam had been out of the picture for a solid 5 and a half months. David is the only man who could possibly be the father of Maddie's baby. I'm thinking that even in the 1980's doctors were able to give fairly accurate information about how far along a pregnancy was. It's a case of sloppy, lazy writing plain and simple. If all these years later I'm still annoyed with this false plot point, do I dare subject myself to season 5??? Stay tuned to find out! LOL